What's New

Resources updated Friday, October 13, 2017

October 13, 2017

The UNESCO logo

"The State Department on Thursday announced America's withdrawal from the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. As with everything that President Trump does, the move provoked journalistic anger and agony. Prepare for years of sob stories about UNESCO heritage sites neglected and aspiring developing-world scientists unfunded, all due to Trumpian unilateralism.

Yet this was a sound and overdue step that will help advance peace and U.N. reform.

In its statement, the State Department cited 'continuing anti-Israel bias' at UNESCO, among other things. The Paris-based agency is far from the only U.N. outfit to single out the Jewish state for opprobrium. But UNESCO's anti-Israel stances have been egregious even by this global body's debased standards, especially since 2011. That was the year the Palestinian Authority sought and won admission to UNESCO as a full member-state. As Jonathan Schanzer of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies told me, 'The Palestinians targeted UNESCO early as part of their Palestine-194 strategy' – the PA effort to win recognition as a state in U.N. halls rather than through talks with Israel. 'UNESCO has played a role in this strategy, and it isn't done yet.'...

The Obama administration denounced the PA's admission, with then-State Department spokeswoman Victoria Nuland calling it 'regrettable, premature' and harmful to 'our shared goal to a comprehensive, just and lasting peace.' Washington cut off American dollars for UNESCO under a Bill Clinton-era law that prohibits the U.S. government from funding any U.N. agency that admits a non-state as a member. American funding, once accounting for more than one-fifth of UNESCO's budget, hasn't been restored since 2011. The agency has lost out on some $600 million as a result.

UNESCO only doubled down on its anti-Israel agitation in the years that followed, however, passing a raft of resolutions that denied the Jewish (and Christian) connection to Jerusalem and other holy sites in Israel...

It was this black record that impelled the Trump administration to withdraw from UNESCO. The decision, by the way, is not without precedent. President Carter withdrew the U.S. from the International Labor Organization for three years and didn't rejoin until the ILO took steps to reform itself. The Reagan administration in 1983 pulled the U.S. out of UNESCO over its 'hostility toward the basic institutions of a free society.' President Reagan was worried about a creepy UNESCO proposal to have the agency and its authoritarian members license and regulate foreign reporters. Washington returned to UNESCO in 2002, under George W. Bush.

By withdrawing from UNESCO (once more), the Trump administration is sending an important message to the U.N. mandarins: that America doesn't have infinite patience for international institutions that function as platforms for Jew-hatred. Long before Donald Trump came on the scene, that used to be a bipartisan American position."

Trump Made the Right Move on UNESCO Article

A sign for the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization

"In withdrawing US membership from UNESCO, President Trump sent a clear sign that the world body's flagrant anti-Israel bias will be met with punitive action, not just rhetorical broadsides.

It's a shame, given Washington's role in creating the UN Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization after World War II. But even by the UN's notoriously corrupt standards, UNESCO's recent behavior has been especially hateful.

The agency has become part and parcel of the Palestinian campaign to erase Jewish connections to the historic land of Israel. UNESCO has even designated such sites as the Western Wall solely by their Muslim names.

As UN Ambassador Nikki Haley rightly said, such 'extreme politicization' (especially to rewrite history, rather than preserve it) 'has become a chronic embarrassment.'...

Just as outrageous as its efforts to eradicate Israel from world culture, UNESCO has retained Syria's government on its human rights committee - even after documented evidence that Bashar al-Assad's regime has committed genocidal war crimes against his own people...

Now Trump has taken strong action. We suspect it won't be the last while the UN continues to violate its own principles."

Exiting UNESCO was the right thing to do Document